Last Updated: 17 September 2026

Retention Rate is the New Engagement Rate: Why Keeping Users Comes First

0 min read
Retention Rate is the New Engagement Rate: Why Keeping Users Comes First
Aurélie BrunetWritten ByAurélie Brunet

As the Director of Performance, Aurélie specialises in creating new business for Propeller through outreach and finding areas in which the company can expand.

In the world of web analytics, engagement metrics have long been king. Tracking likes, shares, comments – all signs a user is actively interacting with your brand. But here’s the truth for today’s digital experts: Retention rate is the new engagement rate.

Don’t get us wrong, engagement is still important. It’s the initial spark that draws users in. But a user who taps “like” once and disappears isn’t driving long-term value. Retention is about building loyalty, keeping users coming back, and ultimately, turning them into advocates for your brand.

Here’s why retention should be your new north star metric:

  • Engagement Doesn’t Guarantee Loyalty: A user who spends hours scrolling through your social media feed isn’t necessarily a loyal customer. They might just be easily distracted. Retention shows users who find true value in your product or service and keep coming back for more.
  • Focus on Lifetime Value: Engaged users might not convert into paying customers. Retention looks beyond the initial interaction and focuses on users who become part of your long-term ecosystem, driving recurring revenue and boosting your lifetime value.
  • Reduced Customer Acquisition Costs: Acquiring new users is expensive. Retaining existing ones is far more cost-effective. By focusing on keeping users happy and engaged, you save resources and build a sustainable business model.

So, How Do We Make Retention Rate the Priority?

  • Shifting your focus to retention requires a data-driven approach. Here are some key strategies:
    • Track the Right Metrics: Go beyond basic engagement metrics. Look at in-app purchases, repeat visits, sign-ups for premium services – all indicators of user commitment.
    • Personalise the User Journey: Tailor your communication and offerings to each user’s needs and behaviour. This builds a deeper connection and increases the value they perceive in your brand.
    • Prioritise User Feedback: Actively solicit and respond to user feedback. Address pain points, improve the user experience, and show users you care about their long-term satisfaction.
    • Nurture Relationships: Don’t let interactions drop off. Use targeted email campaigns, loyalty programs, and exclusive offers to keep users engaged and coming back for more.

    By prioritising retention, you’re building a sustainable business model that thrives on loyal customers. Remember, a single, highly engaged user who disappears might look good on a vanity metric, but a user who consistently finds value in your product or service – that’s the user worth keeping. Make retention your new engagement rate, and watch your business flourish.

    Get in touch with Propeller today to find out how we can help you retain and grow your customer base.

Get in touch

And see how we'd drive results for you

****Read more****

Is your marketing creating growth, or just recording it?

Is your marketing creating growth, or just recording it?

Aurélie Brunet
Aurélie Brunet
22 October
2026
What is Generative Engine Optimisation (GEO)?

What is Generative Engine Optimisation (GEO)?

Matt Ford
Matt Ford
03 September
2026
Digital Marketing Budget Allocation Across Multiple Locations: A Decision Framework

Digital Marketing Budget Allocation Across Multiple Locations: A Decision Framework

Heidi Vorrath
Heidi Vorrath
10 August
2026
What Actually Drives ROI in Hospitality Digital Marketing

What Actually Drives ROI in Hospitality Digital Marketing

Mark Lillicrapp
Mark Lillicrapp
03 June
2026
Winners: Web Excellence Award for Best Website: Wine, Beer & Spirits

Winners: Web Excellence Award for Best Website: Wine, Beer & Spirits

Aurélie Brunet
Aurélie Brunet
20 May
2026
Why Many Hotel Groups Struggle to Scale Digital Platforms

Why Many Hotel Groups Struggle to Scale Digital Platforms

Mark Lillicrapp
Mark Lillicrapp
06 March
2026
The Future of AI in Local Search

The Future of AI in Local Search

Matt Ford
Matt Ford
05 February
2026
Why SEO in 2026 Isn’t About Ranking Anymore – It’s About Being Seen, Trusted, and Understood

Why SEO in 2026 Isn’t About Ranking Anymore – It’s About Being Seen, Trusted, and Understood

Matt Ford
Matt Ford
08 January
2026
Why You Should Be Competing for Visibility in the LLM Era

Why You Should Be Competing for Visibility in the LLM Era

Mark Lillicrapp
Mark Lillicrapp
02 December
2025
Winning in the Age of AI Search: Introducing Propeller’s New AI Solutions

Winning in the Age of AI Search: Introducing Propeller’s New AI Solutions

Mark Lillicrapp
Mark Lillicrapp
04 November
2025
Paid Campaigns Failing to Convert? Here’s Why.

Paid Campaigns Failing to Convert? Here’s Why.

Sally Watanabe
Sally Watanabe
04 November
2025
iOS 26 Privacy Settings: What Universal Link Sanitisation Means for Marketers in Hospitality

iOS 26 Privacy Settings: What Universal Link Sanitisation Means for Marketers in Hospitality

Felix Mutiu
Felix Mutiu
30 September
2025
Top 10 Agencies Redefining Digital Marketing for the Experience Economy in 2025

Top 10 Agencies Redefining Digital Marketing for the Experience Economy in 2025

Heidi Vorrath
Heidi Vorrath
30 September
2025
From Walk-Ins to Pre-Bookings: The Digital Shift in Hospitality

From Walk-Ins to Pre-Bookings: The Digital Shift in Hospitality

Matthew Richardson
Matthew Richardson
23 September
2025
Why Digital Marketing Is the New Crystal Ball for Growth

Why Digital Marketing Is the New Crystal Ball for Growth

Heidi Vorrath
Heidi Vorrath
10 September
2025
The Optimal Digital Channel Mix for Multi-Site Hospitality Brands

The Optimal Digital Channel Mix for Multi-Site Hospitality Brands

Oriana Cirilo
Oriana Cirilo
15 July
2025
The Rise of Bleisure and Extended Stays

The Rise of Bleisure and Extended Stays

Oriana Cirilo
Oriana Cirilo
10 July
2025
Rethinking the Guest Journey in a Digital-First World

Rethinking the Guest Journey in a Digital-First World

Oriana Cirilo
Oriana Cirilo
08 July
2025
5 Digital Trends Disrupting the Property Market

5 Digital Trends Disrupting the Property Market

Oriana Cirilo
Oriana Cirilo
17 June
2025
SEO Is Shifting: Why Your Owned Channels Matter More Than Ever

SEO Is Shifting: Why Your Owned Channels Matter More Than Ever

Matt Evans
Matt Evans
15 May
2025
The Recipe to More Hospitality Bookings: 5 Key Takeaways from our Experiences Webinar

The Recipe to More Hospitality Bookings: 5 Key Takeaways from our Experiences Webinar

Oriana Cirilo
Oriana Cirilo
06 May
2025
Hot Take: 5 Marketing Campaigns We’re Loving Right Now

Hot Take: 5 Marketing Campaigns We’re Loving Right Now

Imogen Haylock
Imogen Haylock
30 April
2025
Propeller Nominated for Two UK Digital Excellence Awards 2025

Propeller Nominated for Two UK Digital Excellence Awards 2025

Imogen Haylock
Imogen Haylock
25 March
2025
Propeller Shortlisted for Best Agency to Work For

Propeller Shortlisted for Best Agency to Work For

Imogen Haylock
Imogen Haylock
21 March
2025
A Day In The Life Of A Project Coordinator

A Day In The Life Of A Project Coordinator

Shania Samuels
Shania Samuels
06 March
2025
2025 Hospitality Trends: What’s Coming and Why It Matters

2025 Hospitality Trends: What’s Coming and Why It Matters

Imogen Haylock
Imogen Haylock
19 February
2025
Rednote: The Social Media App on the Rise Amid TikTok’s Looming U.S. Ban

Rednote: The Social Media App on the Rise Amid TikTok’s Looming U.S. Ban

Ellie Strestik
Ellie Strestik
30 January
2025
This Year in Focus: What’s On For Propeller in 2025

This Year in Focus: What’s On For Propeller in 2025

Imogen Haylock
Imogen Haylock
22 January
2025
Top Social Media Agencies in the UK (2026)

Top Social Media Agencies in the UK (2026)

Ellie Strestik
Ellie Strestik
19 January
2025
Top Hospitality Agencies in the US (2025-2026)

Top Hospitality Agencies in the US (2025-2026)

Matthew Richardson
Matthew Richardson
17 January
2025